Talent Management: The Often Vexing “Lack of Sharing” Issue in Knowledge Management

This post explores one of the common issues that face many organizations as they attempt to transfer knowledge across their organizations and explores why it is so vexing.  This is inspired by a 22 May, 2011 Vancouver Province Article titled “Holding out on coworkers”, by Jordan Press, page A41. The article reviews some of the findings and thoughts in a research paper done by University of Toronto professor David Zweig.

The article explores why people don’t share knowledge (usually in the form of wisdom, savviness and other “tricks of the trade”) and how to deal with this behaviour.

Why people don’t share?

  1. They don’t trust their coworker and what they might do with the information (e.g., take undue credit).
  2. The organizations has done a poor job of promoting inter-office sharing. Actually becomes in people’s best interests to secure their “especially effective” knowledge.

What can we do to improve the situation?

  1. having more direct communication and less reliance on email
  2. highlighting examples of trustworthiness
  3. avoiding “betrayal” incentives such as rewarding those who poach others’ knowledge.

Of the three ideas above, only the third one I find particularly substantial. It is not that the first two can’t have some benefits, I just don’t believe they are powerful enough tactics to make a material difference if the third one is left unaddressed. I will delve into this more below.

The issue of successful knowledge transference is a well recognized one in business and OD. In the early years it was thought we could codify this knowledge using sophisticated software systems and getting people to load in their wisdom. I remember going to thinly veiled vendor presentations and conferences and coming away with a headache over the proposed approaches. They were just too complicated, way to time consuming (when everyone was working flat out – especially those whose knowledge we were desperate to “capture”), and these approaches failed badly on why people were unlikely to embrace this effort. The knowledge that was easiest to codify was the that which was already process and procedurally organized. The knowledge that really mattered was the the “tacit” type.

For me, I see one critical contributor to failure to share: Those that have the knowledge often don’t know how. Time for the mental experiment:

Think of an area you are really good in and ask yourself the question (as if you were uninformed about your field): “How do you know to do that?” Not easy to answer is it. Why? Because you have internalized the expertise and wisdom such that it is no longer a “conscious” thought process. Guess what, your best people operate that way too.

I always want to mention this alternative basis for sharing difficulties as it is a factor and not a blaming one.

Let’ think about the more conscious and deliberate forms of withholding.

Readers of this BLOG know I have a focus on role design and performance as a critical strategy area for successful talent management. I would like to also remind us that roles are designed within a context. The context includes values, macro systems, processes and so on.

My observance is that these context factors are huge in the matter of behaviour. Overt formal – to – covert informal recognition and reward systems I would argue drive most conscious and deliberate knowledge withholding. People learn what is “safe” and “not safe” and act accordingly. Hence, when I work with clients on the knowledge transfer type issues, I always pay particular attention to how the organization explicitly and implicitly reinforces specific sharing/non-sharing behaviours.

Given this perspective, I am not overly convinced that relying on face-to-face communications and sharing success stories are sufficient or even meaningful strategies for getting more useful sharing behaviour habits started and engrained.

When I have found the reinforcing patterns to be a significant contributor to withholding behaviours, I have worked with clients to moderate these role specific contextual factors, rather than, trying to change the organizations’ related systems.

Your thoughts?


About 123stilllearning456

As a management consultant I am passionately interested in talent management and risk/uncertainty issues. In the area of talent management I propose that we seek strategies that look beyond the staffing/employee centric frames of reference. I have been frustrated at the "closing down on possibilities" by these more conventional staffing/employee centric approaches. I have been impressed where people have found systematic solutions to their talent management issues by going beyond the conventional approaches. In the area of risk and uncertainty, I am interested in making this topic relevant to more normal decision making situations. My conceptual foundation is to use the micro-economist's fixed/variable cost theme. I also think it is important to look at these issues for people through their emotional and psychological lens. As a premise I think risk and uncertainty only exist where there is a person who cares about possible events and its consequences. Hence, risk and uncertainty are social based concepts (no sentience, no risk and uncertainty). A major influence on my thinking in this area is Nassim Taleb of "Black Swan" fame. This BLOG provides me with an opportunity to express my thoughts on topics that interest me. As this is an online diary, content is more important to me than polish. I apologize if this distracts from readers' enjoyment and learning. Still I find this a useful way to live up to my namesake, learn more from others and hopefully provoke creative thoughts and ideas in others.
This entry was posted in Talent Manangement. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s